Steely Dan “Gaucho”
/How I ever got to be 65 years old without having friends who regularly use the phrase “High in the Custerdome” as shorthand (for something!) would seem to be one of my major failings in life. Maybe it’s merely because I have few friends and none of them happen to be Steely Dan fanatics, at least to the degree I am, but it could also be that—seeing how Becker and Fagen refused to ever give a straight answer about what that means (good for them!)—perhaps we’re a little wary it could refer to something untoward, such as age inappropriate relationships or humor that some Native Americans might find offensive. Don’t need to get cancelled once again! Of course, it’s possible that the “real story” came out in an interview or something I might have missed—though you’d think the algorithm would have shoved that in my face by now—in one of those articles requiring you to click though 65 ads to get to the unsatisfying conclusion. Also, I do have my own theory, which is admittedly a little nuts (but then, so is that line, in the chorus from the title track, right?)—though I’m convinced my interpretation is “spot on”—but I’m not going to repeat it here, as it’s discussed in my “review” of the song, on the Steely Dan page of my website (rspeen.com) —which reminds me, I need to get back to that! At any rate, I’m not going to talk about the album, song by song, here, since my favorite approach to SD has been focusing on a song at a time, with particular emphasis on the lyrics—which is why I’ve found the band, since I’ve initiated that approach, more fascinating than ever. Here, I’m just going think about the album as a whole—and try to keep it short. Good luck with that—it’s already not short!
Besides Pretzel Logic, it’s my favorite of their album covers—mysterious and distant-feeling art, from Argentina, I guess, that seems to be on a wall. It’s very cool. You’d guess it was jazz album. I barely remember what record buying felt like in 1980, actually, but I don’t recall this fitting in anywhere. I don’t think I bought it at that time—I was through with Steely Dan. I’m trying to listen to it right now with fresh ears—totally impossible. Though, had I put it aside for 45 years, it might be. I’ve listened to this record a lot over the past few years, however, as I’ve slowly started to come around to it. There was a time that, not only was it my least favorite SD record, but also, I kind of despised it—I found it bland and insipid. But about 10 years ago, or so, as I became, somehow, a bigger fan of the band in general, I decided I’d make appreciating this album a project, and I’ve slowly come around to it. I know that for some “Dan” (as the fans say) fans, this one is the absolute pinnacle—or if not, second to Aja or maybe The Royal Scam—and I respect that opinion. Part of my increased geekdom has included ranking the albums, ranking all the songs, and seeking out the oddities and adjacent records. I’m a bit over that, now, but it’s a lot of fun to approach certain music that way—that’s part of what being a fan is about.
My best approach with Steely Dan, however, as I said, is a song at a time (picking them at random)—to go as deep as possible with the song—many listenings, headphones, following the lyrics, etc. It’s not like their albums don’t mean anything as albums, but you can really approach each song as something to be reckoned with. They don’t have weak songs, or filler, not at all. Most bands have primarily filler, to go along with their “hits.” Writing a great song is not easy, and even one on an album is an accomplishment. There are only seven songs on this record, but they’re all great. Each one has an epic feeling. I have written short articles about a few of them, now, and not surprisingly, those are my favorites, at this point. And even though I’m not going through this record, here, now, song by song, I’ll admit that on this date my favorite is the song, “Gaucho”—and it’s a challenge for me to even figure out why. It could be the contrast between what I find a really off-putting opening (that first verse almost makes me want to puke) and the overly slick yet sleazy saxophone, throughout—the contrast with all that and the really lovely, lush chorus, which is the musical equivalent of falling in love.
Besides that, “Time Out of Mind” is the funniest song—and again, that’s partly due to contrasts—it’s so happy and easy sounding, while the lyrics are just pretty grim. While I’ll likely never have any idea what “Gaucho” is about, if this one isn’t about a love affair with hard drugs, then I need to turn in my Hardy Boys Detective Handbook. Sure, maybe it’s all metaphorical. Ha. Anyway, those are two songs I’ve taken the time to put under my major nerd microscope, and my appreciation for them has prospered. Along with “Hey Nineteen,” which I maintain is generally misunderstood. And that’s all I’m going say, for now, except that I repeatedly have an odd sensation while listening to this as a full vinyl album—which is: As few songs as there are—Side A feels like a full course, and then the first three songs on Side B feel like a full side—and that last song, “Third World Man,” almost feels like a bonus track, or a single—like it almost doesn’t fit—but not in a bad way. It’s a really beautiful song, a bit melancholy, and I guess, like disappearing down a dark road. Maybe it’s because this was the end of Steely Dan. Did we or did we not know that, or get that, at the time? Of course, it was, and it wasn’t. It is, and it isn’t.
6.6.25