In the Sunken Garden

In the Sunken Garden by Frances K. Judd (1939) A Kay Tracey Mystery. Number 12 in the series. I believe this one was written by Mildred Benson (who wrote an amazing number of kids’ books) but it’s just the second Kay Tracey book I’ve read—they are not easy to find. Kay is like a cross between Nancy Drew (good at nearly everything) and Frank White in King of New York (1990)—a young ruffian robs her, and what does she do? Offers him a job! She’s got a living mom, who is pretty cool, so that’s a nice twist. Cousin Bill, who is a lawyer, lives with them—but he disappears for an alarming part of the book, when they really need him, which almost takes on comic overtones. Her able, best friends are sisters— twins (wasted potential in this story!) who are a little annoying, especially the one who keeps spouting poetry. Kay’s rival is a jealous, mean girl who you almost have to feel sorry for. But anyway, this is a great, convoluted mystery—mostly because it’s about an elusive girl in town who looks exactly like Kay! So much so that at one point Kay is easily impersonating her (to try to get to the bottom of things) and the girl’s beau is totally fooled and proposes to Kay! There are so many instances of people confusing the two that I thought of that song, “Double Trouble,” by Half Japanese—great song! Another crazy thing is when a stray dog “adopts” Kay, also fooled about her identity. Apparently his eyes are better than his dog olfaction! But he’s a great, super intelligent dog—a German Shepherd, so naturally Kay names him Jerry. Later, it turns out that that is his name—which is kind of fishy—but then I started to think that maybe this is no mere coincidence of looks—maybe this girl is actually Kay’s doppelgänger! After all, they are both dancers, they both injure their ankles, both are without fathers—it’s all pretty eerie! By the end, I figured you can take it all literally, if you want—but the more mysterious and supernatural reading is there for you—if you don’t mind (and I, for one, don’t) a mystery that has some ambiguity, and isn’t really solved in the end!

10.13.26