The Secret of the Caves

The Secret of the Caves by Franklin W. Dixon (1929) Even though you can't beat the title of this book (The Secret of the Caves!), it's not a very good Hardy Boy mystery. It's probably my least favorite of the ones I've read lately. It's written by Leslie McFarlane, the original Hardy Boys author, but remember, he was just cranking these out (and other series books) for a meager paycheck. The writing is pretty flaccid, especially the adventure segments, which is what most of the book is... one rescue after another, that includes the sea, cliffs, and caves. Not enough mystery and too much danger, for me. Either of the Hardys could have been killed three or four times—really, the series should have been over after seven books, ending with friends putting flowers on their graves. There's the usual storm that comes up suddenly, at least (my favorite story element), and there are some pretty good descriptions of these mind-numbingly vast caves. What is kind of weird is the last book (The Shore Road Mystery) also took place at the caves, and one of criminals in that story has escaped from jail. The Hardys re-capture him (a guy named Carl Schaum!) only because they happen upon him while he's drunk and passed out on the beach! That's just a side plot, but the main story is similarly only solved due to coincidence. There's just not enough food, not enough hijinks, and most of all, not enough weirdness to make this a memorable Hardy Boys adventure. The good thing is that the next book, The Mystery of Cabin Island, is one the best, if not the best.